Immunotherapy of DC-CIK cells enhances the efficacy of chemotherapy for solid cancer: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials in Chinese patients

Immunotherapy of DC-CIK cells enhances the efficacy of chemotherapy for solid cancer: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials in Chinese patients DC-CIK细胞免疫治疗联合化疗对实体肿瘤疗效的荟萃分析 first-author corresp ‡Corresponding Author ‡Corresponding Author †E-mail:xqhgege@hotmail.com †E-mail:xqhgege@hotmail.com xqhgege@hotmail.com Minimally Invasive Urology Center, Shandong Provincial Hospital Affiliated to Shandong University, Jinan 250014, China Minimally Invasive Urology Center, Shandong Provincial Hospital Affiliated to Shandong University, Jinan 250014, China Objective: 2 Professional antigen-presenting dendritic cells (DCs) and cytokine-induced killer (CIK) cells, components of anti-cancer therapy, have shown clinical benefits and potential to overcome chemotherapeutic resistance. To evaluate whether DC-CIK cell-based therapy improves the clinical efficacy of chemotherapy, we reviewed the literature on DC-CIK cells and meta-analyzed randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Methods: 2 We searched several databases and selected studies using predefined criteria. RCTs that applied chemotherapy with and without DC-CIK cells separately in two groups were included. Odds ratio (OR) and mean difference (MD) were reported to measure the pooled effect. Results: 2 Twelve reported RCTs (826 patients), which were all performed on Chinese patients, were included. Combination therapy exhibited better data than chemotherapy: 1-year overall survival (OS) (OR=0.22, P < 0.01), 2-year OS (OR=0.28, P < 0.01), 3-year OS (OR=0.41, P < 0.01), 1-year disease-free survival (DFS) (OR=0.16, P < 0.05), 3-year DFS (OR=0.32, P < 0.01), objective response rate (ORR) (OR=0.54, P < 0.01), and disease control rate (DCR) (OR=0.46, P < 0.01). Moreover, the levels of CD3 + T-lymphocytes (MD=−11.65, P < 0.05) and CD4 + T-lymphocytes (MD=−8.18, P < 0.01) of the combination group were higher. Conclusions: 2 Immunotherapy of DC-CIK cells may enhance the efficacy of chemotherapy on solid cancer and induces no specific side effect. Further RCTs with no publishing bias should be designed to confirm the immunotherapeutic effects of DC-CIK cells. 目的 2 分析和研究DC-CIK细胞免疫治疗是否能够增强化疗在实体肿瘤中的疗效。 创新点 2 首次荟萃分析了关于DC-CIK细胞免疫治疗联合化疗治疗肿瘤疗效的随机对照试验，并从多个角度对疗效进行综合评价。 方法 2 通过文献检索及筛选，收集关于化疗联合DC-CIK细胞免疫治疗的随机对照试验（图1），并从中提取相关数据进行荟萃分析。总生存率（OS）、无病生存率（DFS）、客观缓解率（ORR）、疾病控制率（DFS）和治疗后T淋巴细胞亚型水平是本研究中的主要疗效指标，比值比（OR）（图3、4和5）以及平均差（MD）（图6）用来评价各个指标的综合效应。 结论 2 共有12个随机对照试验被纳入我们的研究中（表1和2）。相对于单独应用化疗，DC-CIK细胞治疗联合化疗的综合疗法能在1年生存率、2年生存率、3年生存率、1年无病生存率、3年无病生存率、客观缓解率以及疾病控制率等指标上有明显优势，且接受综合疗法患者的CD3 + T淋巴细胞和CD4 + T淋巴细胞水平明显更高。综上所述，DC-CIK细胞免疫治疗能够增强化疗对实体肿瘤的疗效。 Solid carcinoma Meta-analysis Dendritic cells Cytokine-induced killer cells Immunotherapy 实体肿瘤 荟萃分析 树突状细胞 细胞因子诱导杀伤细胞 免疫治疗 Introduction 1 Patients of malignant cancer often suffer from the adverse effects of common therapies (surgery, radiotherapy, or chemotherapy). These treatments extend survival time, but may result in low quality-of-life. Small remnant lesions in situ and metastatic cancer cells are the main reasons for recurrence. Immunotherapy, using various methods to restore and enhance the immune abilities of patients to eliminate cancer cells, is an alternative and promising option in treating cancers (Liu et al., 2009 2009 ). Immunotherapy overcomes immunosuppression induced by cancer, surgery, or chemotherapeutic agents (Shi et al., 2012 2012 ). Diverse immunologic cells have been used in immunotherapy (Niu et al., 2011 2011 ). Cytokine-induced killer (CIK) cells, considered as the most cytotoxic immunologic effector cells, originate in vitro after being incubated with lymphocytes with CD3 monoclonal antibody (CD3McAb), interleukin (IL), and interferon (IFN) (Linn et al., 2002 2002 ). Schmidt-Wolf et al. ( 1991 1991 ) reported the anti-cancer potential of CIK cells and confirmed that CIK cells suppress the tumor burden and prolong survival of the murine severe combined immune deficiency (SCID)/human lymphoma models for the first time. Clinical studies have shown high efficiency, low toxicity (Liu et al., 2012 2012 ), and prolonged overall survival (OS) and disease-free survival (DFS) after CIK treatment (Hao et al., 2010 2010 ; Pan et al., 2010 2010 ). Dendritic cells (DCs) can process and present antigens to T-lymphocytes. Different kinds of DC-vaccines have shown anti-tumor effects (Palucka et al., 2010 2010 ; Baek et al., 2012 2012 ). The innate quality of DCs in antigen presenting could effectively counteract the specificity deficiency and enhance the cytotoxicity of CIK cells. A rising number of studies (Thanendrarajan et al., 2011 2011 ; Wang et al., 2014a 2014a ; Zhong et al., 2014 2014 ) on the combination of active and passive immunotherapy have shown improved anti-tumor immune responses. Synergistic use of CIK cells and docetaxel demonstrated a stronger anti-tumor effect in several multidrug-resistant lung adenocarcinoma cell lines (Liu et al., 2009 2009 ). The property of antagonistic drug resistance of DC-CIK cells makes it appropriate for improving the clinical outcome of chemotherapy. However, there is still no consensus on the utility of DC-CIK cells against solid cancers because of the lack of large-sample clinical trials. Accordingly, we meta-analyzed clinical randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and evaluated whether the DC-CIK therapy enhances anti-tumor activity and optimizes clinical outcomes. Methods 1 Literature search 2 We searched MEDLINE, PubMed, SinoMed, and ClinicalTrials.gov, using the keywords “cytokine-induced-killer” and “cancer” in English and Chinese languages. Free-text search was also performed. We also requested more clinical information by contacting drug manufacturers. Eligibility criteria 2 The main criteria for study inclusion were as follows: (1) RCTs, (2) the two arms in the study were chemotherapy and DC-CIK combined with chemotherapy, and (3) patients included were histologically confirmed as having solid cancer. Main criteria for study exclusion were as follows: (1) phase I clinical study, (2) cohort studies, (3) retrospective study, (4) hematological cancer, or (5) use of DCs or CIK cells as simple regimen of immunotherapy. Data extraction 2 Two reviewers extracted data independently. Any discrepancies were resolved by consensus. Data extracted are as follows: name of author, year of publication, number of patients, type of cancer, median age, treatment duration, median follow-up, median DFS, median OS, complete response (CR), partial response (PR), and stable disease (SD). Definition of outcome measurement 2 The primary endpoint in the analysis was OS. Other endpoints were DFS, disease control rate (DCR: CR+PR+SD), and objective response rate (ORR: CR+PR). Statistical analysis 2 Cochrane Collaboration’s tool was applied to judge risk of bias, containing seven items. Statistical analysis was performed mainly by comparison of two arms of therapy using Review Manager 5.0 (Nordic Cochrane Centre, Cochrane Collaboration, Copenhagen, Denmark). Cochrane’s Q -test and I 2 (the corresponding quantity) demonstrated statistical heterogeneity among studies, and helped us choose an appropriate analysis model (fixed-effect model or random-effect model), with the significance threshold predefined as 0.1. For dichotomous variables (OS, DFS, DCR, and ORR), we calculated the pooled odds ratio (OR) of studies with the statistical method of Mantel-Haenszel to reflect the clinical effect of treatment, and pooled OR of < 1 indicated that the combination therapy showed the preferred outcome. For continuous variables (number of T-lymphocyte subtypes), we calculated the mean difference (MD) of two arms of therapy. STATA 12.0 (STATA Co., College Station, TX, USA) was also applied for analysis. P- values of < 0.05 indicated statistical significance. Results 1 Selection of studies 2 Five hundreds and ninety-eight studies, including 300 from MEDLINE and PubMed, 43 registered in ClinicalTrials.gov, and 255 from SinoMed, were analyzed initially. Of these, 489 were excluded because of lack of an immunotherapy arm, absence of clinical trial, or duplication. Fifty-five studies were excluded because of lack of evidence to prove that they are RCTs, leaving 26 articles in English and 28 articles in Chinese. Finally, 12 RCTs that used chemotherapy with and without DC-CIK separately as two arms were included (Fig. 1 1 ). Quality assessment 2 Random sequence generation of nine studies were judged as low risk and the remaining three studies lacked relevant depiction. However, allocation concealment was not feasible owing to the difference of treatment procedures between groups and was not described in sufficient detail in all studies. Risks of blinding and incomplete outcome data were low. Eight studies were of unclear risk in terms of selective reporting, and the other four studies were considered at high risk because of the lack of primary outcome data (Fig. 2 2 ). (a) Risk of bias in each study. (b) Overall result of each item in quality assessment. DcZhu2011C, DcZhong2011L, DcZhang2011C, DcYuan2013L, DcYuan2011L, DcYuan2011C, DcSheng2011L, DcRen2013B, DcNi2013B, DcLi2012C, DcLi2009L, and DcGao2014G represent the studies as shown in Table 1 1 Patients’ characteristics of included trials 2 Twelve RCTs, available as published articles including 826 patients in total, were included. Distribution of gender and the median age of patients between groups had no significant differences. Table 1 1 summarizes the therapeutic regimens and other characteristics of included patients. NSCLC: non-small cell lung cancer; NP: vinorelbine and platinum; FOLFOX: 5-fluorouracil/leucovorin/oxaliplatin; FOLFIRI: 5-fluorouracil/leucovorin/irinotecan; CF: calcium folinate; 5-Fu: 5F-dUMP; SDC: standard-dose chemotherapy; HDC: high-dose chemotherapy; AT: docetaxel and doxorubicin 2 Study ID 2 Cancer type 2 Receiving surgery previously 3 Chemo group 3 Combination group Regimen Number of patients/males Median age (year) Regimen Number of patients/males Median age (year) DcLi2009L (Li et al., 2009 2009 ) NSCLC Yes Navelbine+cisplatin 42/28 60.5 DC-CIK+cisplatin+navelbine 42/28 61 DcZhong2011L (Zhong et al., 2011 2011 ) NSCLC No NP 14/7 DC-CIK+NP (vinorelbine with platinum) 14/6 DcYuan2011L (Yuan et al., 2011a 2011a ) NSCLC No Chemotherapy (unclear) 32/20 66 DC-CIK+chemotherapy (unclear) 32/22 67.5 DcSheng2011L (Sheng et al., 2011 2011 ) NSCLC No NP 33 DC-CIK+NP 32 DcZhang2011C (Zhang et al., 2011 2011 ) Rectal cancer No FOLFOX/FOLFIRI 31 DC-CIK+FOLFOX/FOLFIRI 32 DcYuan2011C (Yuan et al., 2011b 2011b ) Colorectal cancer No Chemotherapy (unclear) 21/16 58 DC-CIK+chemotherapy (unclear) 21/15 60 DcZhu2011C (Zhu et al., 2011 2011 ) Colorectal cancer No CF+5-Fu 43/27 58.3 DC-CIK+CF+5-Fu 40/24 59.2 DcLi2012C (Li et al., 2012 2012 ) Colon cancer No Oxaliplatin+CF+5-Fu 20/15 57.5 DC-CIK+CF+5-Fu+oxaliplatin 20/13 54.5 DcRen2013B (Ren et al., 2013 2013 ) Breast cancer No SDC 79 52 DC-CIK+HDC 87 50 DcYuan2013L (Yuan et al., 2013 2013 ) NSCLC No Platinum-based doublet chemotherapy 44 DC-CIK+Platinum-based doublet chemotherapy 31 DcNi2013B (Ni et al., 2013 2013 ) Breast cancer Yes AT 26 51 DC-CIK+AT 36 49 DcGao2014G (Gao et al., 2014 2014 ) Gastric/colorectal cancer Yes Chemotherapy (unclear) 27/16 64.48 DC-CIK+chemotherapy (unclear) 27/16 61.56 Characteristics of DC-CIK cell therapy 2 In all studies, autologous mononuclear cells were collected from patients and cultivated in medium. Adherent cells were then cultured with granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), IFN-γ, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α, interleukin (IL)-4, and autologous tumor antigen, and finally the DCs were harvested. Suspension cells were cultured in a medium containing IFN-γ, CD3McAb, and IL, transforming to CIK cells. Table 2 2 summarizes details of culture and regimens of DC-CIK cells. GM-CSF: granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor; CD3McAb: CD3 monoclonal antibody; CEA: carcino-embryonic antigen; LPS: lipopolysaccharide; IFN: interferon; IL: interleukin; Ag: antigen Study ID DC-CIK cell regimen Culture of CIK cells Culture of DC cells DcLi2009L (Li et al., 2009 2009 ) Two times of (13.07±1.37)×10 9 cells at 1-d intervals CD3McAb, IL-1α, IFN-γ, IL-2 GM-CSF, autologous tumor lysate DcZhong2011L (Zhong et al., 2011 2011 ) (8.1±2.5)×10 6 DC cells and (13.3±3.5)×10 8 CIK cells IFN-γ, CD3-Ab, IL-2 GM-CSF, IL-4, CEA peptide DcYuan2011L (Yuan et al., 2011a 2011a ) Four times of DC-CIK cell transfusion Unclear Unclear DcSheng2011L (Sheng et al., 2011 2011 ) Two courses of 5×10 9 cells for four times IFN-γ, CD3McAb, IL-1α, IL-2 GM-CSF, IL-4, TNF-α DcZhang2011C (Zhang et al., 2011 2011 ) Three times of cells > 1×10 7 L −1 IFN-γ, IL-2, CD3McAb, IL-1 GM-CSF, IL-4, autologous tumor Ag, TNF-2α DcYuan2011C (Yuan et al., 2011b 2011b ) DC cells > 10 6 ml −1 and CIK cells > 10 10 ml −1 IFN-γ, CD3McAb, IL-1α, IL-2 GM-CSF, IL-4, IFN-γ, TNF-2α DcZhu2011C (Zhu et al., 2011 2011 ) 5×10 5 U/L CIK cells and (3–7)×10 7 DC cells IFN-γ, CD3McAb, IL-2 IFN-γ, LPS DcLi2012C (Li et al., 2012 2012 ) Two courses of transfusion on the 14, 15, 16 d of cell culture IFN-γ, CD3McAb, IL-2 GM-CSF, IL-4, IFN-γ DcRen2013B (Ren et al., 2013 2013 ) Transfusion at every 4 d interval for three cycles starting 1 week before chemotherapy IFN-γ, CD3, IL-2 GM-CSF, IL-4, TNF-α DcYuan2013L (Yuan et al., 2013 2013 ) 10 10 cells transfused 7 d after the lastchemotherapy and continued for 4 d IL-2, CD3McAb, phytohemagglutinin, IFN-γ GM-CSF DcNi2013B (Ni et al., 2013 2013 ) Six times of transfusion from the 7th day of cell culture IFN-γ, CD3McAb, IL-2 GM-CSF, IL-4, autologous tumor Ag, TNF-α DcGao2014G (Gao et al., 2014 2014 ) Two cycles repeated 3 to 5 times in 2 weeks, from the 2nd or 3th day after chemotherapy IFN-γ, CD3McAb, IL-2, gentamycin GM-CSF, IL-4, autologous tumor Ag Efficacy assessments 2 Overall survival 3 Six studies, which included 352 patients, reported 1-year OS. The 1-year OS rates in the chemo group (in which patients received chemotherapy only) and the combination group (in which patients received a combination of DC-CIK cells and chemotherapy) were 71.19% and 89.14%, respectively. OR in only one study (DcZhu2011C; Fig. 3a 3a ) showed statistical significance independently, but when the studies were integrated, the general OR was 0.22 ( P< 0.0001), indicating a significantly better 1-year OS in the combination group than in the chemo group (Fig. 3a 3a ). (a) Comparison of OS across groups. (b) Mean OS of three studies (DcLi2009L, DcZhong2011L, and DcGao2014G) Information on 2-year OS was analyzed from six studies, which covered 352 patients. The 2-year OS rates in the chemo group and the combination group were 55.93% and 72.57%, respectively. All studies showed a longer 2-year OS in the combination group than in chemo group, among which only one (DcGao2014G; Fig. 3a 3a ) exhibited statistical significance. OR of 0.28 ( P< 0.0001) indicated that the general 2-year OS in the combination group was significantly longer compared with the chemo group (Fig. 3a 3a ). Three-year OS, which was available in five studies including 397 patients, was 31.79% in the chemo group and 44.55% in the combination group. All five studies exhibited prolonged 3-year OS, among which one (DcGao2014G; Fig. 3a 3a ) showed statistical significance independently. OR was 0.41 ( P= 0.0009), suggesting overall 3-year OS in the combination group was significantly longer than that in the chemo group (Fig. 3a 3a ). Three studies (DcLi2009L, DcZhong2011L, and DcGao2014G; Fig. 3a 3a ) reported 1-, 2-, and 3-year OS. The average %OS of the 3 years was calculated and shown using scatter plots with linear trend lines of each group ( R 2 =0.9868 in the chemo group; R 2 =0.9980 in the combination group). Average %OS in the chemo group was 83.13%, 65.05%, and 53.01%, respectively, while %OS in the combination group was 92.77%, 85.54%, and 77.11%, respectively (Fig. 3b 3b ). Disease-free survival 3 One-year DFS, which was available in only two studies including 138 patients, was 82.61% in the chemo group and 97.10% in the combination group. All studies exhibited prolonged 1-year DFS and OR was 0.16 ( P= 0.01), indicating that the overall 1-year DFS in the combination group was significantly better. A fixed-effect analysis model was used (Fig. 4a 4a ). (a) Comparison of DFS across groups. (b) Mean DFS of two studies (DcLi2009L and DcGao2014G) Information of 2-year DFS also came from two studies. The 2-year DFS rates in the chemo group and the combination group were 63.77% and 78.26%, respectively. All studies showed longer 2-year DFS in the combination group than in the chemo group. Overall OR of 0.49 ( P= 0.06) indicated no significant difference between groups (Fig. 4a 4a ). Three-year DFS was 50.72% and 75.36% in the chemo group and the combination group, respectively. OR in only one study (DcGao2014G, Fig. 4a 4a ) showed independent statistical significance, but when the studies were integrated, the general OR was 0.32 ( P= 0.003), showing a significantly better 3-year DFS in the combination group than in the chemo group (Fig. 4a 4a ). Two studies (DcLi2009L and DcGao2014G; Fig. 4a 4a ) reported 1-, 2-, and 3-year DFS at the same time. The average %DFS of 3 years was shown using scatter plots combining linear trend lines of each group ( R 2 =0.9891 in the chemo group; R 2 =0.8480 in the combination group; Fig. 4b 4b ). ORR and DCR 3 Six studies, covering 431 patients, reported CR and PR at the same time, and the ORR was 29.95% in the chemo group and 42.86% in the combination group. OR in all six studies showed better ORR and only one study (Ren et al., 2013 2013 ) showed statistical significance, and an overall OR of 0.54 ( P= 0.004) implied that DC-CIK cells significantly raise ORR. A fixed-effect analysis model was used (Fig. 5 5 ). DCR, which was available in five studies including 367 patients, was 65.71% in the chemo group and 80.21% in the combination group. All five studies exhibited better DCR, of which one (Ren et al., 2013 2013 ) showed statistical significance. Pooled OR was 0.46 ( P= 0.001), indicating that DCR in the combination group was significantly better than that in the chemo group (Fig. 5 5 ). T-lymphocyte subtypes in peripheral blood 3 Seven studies (417 patients in total) tested the level of CD3 + T-lymphocytes after treatment, among which six concluded that the level of CD3 + T-lymphocytes in the combination group was higher. The other study (Li et al., 2012 2012 ) reported totally contradicting results. The pooled MD of two groups, which was −11.65 ( P= 0.02), showed that patients who received DC-CIK and chemotherapy were proven to have a significantly higher level of CD3 + T-lymphocytes. A random-effect analysis model was used (Fig. 6a 6a ). (a) Comparison of post-treatment T-lymphocytes and ratio of CD4 + /CD8 + T-lymphocytes. (b) Comparison of post-treatment CD8 + T-lymphocytes The level of CD4 + T-lymphocytes and ratio of CD4 + /CD8 + T-lymphocytes of patients who received DC-CIK cells treatment were higher. The pooled MD were −8.18 ( P< 0.0001) and −0.40 ( P= 0.0006), respectively (Fig. 6a 6a ). CD8 + T-lymphocytes test showed a different result. Three out of seven studies revealed significantly higher level of CD8 + T-lymphocytes in the combination group (Sheng et al., 2011 2011 ; Zhu et al., 2011 2011 ; Ni et al., 2013 2013 ); one study reported a contradictory result (Li et al., 2012 2012 ); and the remaining three did not show any difference between the groups. Pooled MD was −4.23 ( P= 0.25), suggesting no significant difference in terms of CD8 + T-lymphocytes level between treatment groups (Fig. 6b 6b ). Comparison of efficacy in different types of cancer 2 Included were 12 studies focusing on different types of cancer, including non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), breast cancer, and gastrointestinal cancer (mainly colorectal cancer). Comparison of OS, clinical response, and T-lymphocytes subtypes in two groups was performed in different types of cancer. Only two of twelve studies focused on breast cancer (Ren et al., 2013 2013 ; Ni et al., 2013 2013 ) and most items excepting ORR and DCR were available only in one study (Ni et al., 2013 2013 ). CD4 + , CD4 + /CD8 + , and DCR of NSCLC and 3-year OS of gastrointestinal cancer were also extracted from one study (Gao et al., 2014 2014 ). Other comparisons were performed in at least two RCTs. ORs of 1-, 2-, and 3-year OS between groups in gastrointestinal cancer were all lower than those in NSCLC. ORs of ORR and DCR were similar, but only comparison of breast cancer exhibited statistical significance, which indicated that the combination group showed a better clinical response than the chemo group (Table 3 3 ). The combination group showed significantly higher levels of CD3 + , CD4 + T-lymphocytes, and CD4 + /CD8 + ratio of NSCLC and breast cancer patients. Comparison of CD3 + T-lymphocytes and CD4 + /CD8 + ratio of gastrointestinal cancer patients showed no statistical significance. Difference of CD8 + T-lymphocytes between treatment groups in breast cancer showed statistical significance (Table 4 4 ). P -value was for overall effect. P< 0.05, difference was considered to be statistically significant Cancer type 1-year OS 2-year OS 3-year OS ORR DCR NSCLC 0.48 ( P= 0.24) 0.29 ( P= 0.04) * * 0.35 ( P= 0.02) * * 0.67 ( P= 0.32) 0.44 ( P= 0.38) Gastrointestinal cancer 0.16 ( P< 0.0001) * * 0.27 ( P= 0.0009) * * 0.14 ( P= 0.002) * * 0.47 ( P= 0.06) 0.52 ( P= 0.20) Breast cancer 0.76 ( P= 0.49) 0.51 ( P= 0.04) * * 0.44 ( P= 0.005) * * P- value was for overall effect. P< 0.05, difference was considered to be statistically significant Cancer type CD3 + CD4 + CD4 + /CD8 + CD8 + NSCLC −12.13 ( P= 0.02) * * −5.43 ( P= 0.0004) * * −0.44 ( P= 0.001) * * −7.41 ( P= 0.36) Gastrointestinal cancer −7.64 ( P= 0.28) −6.71 ( P= 0.002) * * −0.35 ( P= 0.06) −1.44 ( P= 0.80) Breast cancer −27.44 ( P< 0.00001) * * −17.37 ( P< 0.00001) * * −0.51 ( P< 0.00001) * * −9.08 ( P< 0.00001) * * Adverse effects 2 Fever was the most common adverse effect in the combination group. Transfusion of DC-CIK cells to patients was assumed to induce its occurrence. Most patients experienced fever of 37.2–39.5 °C, and most of them recovered spontaneously without any treatment except some who received antipyretic treatment. Other adverse effects including headache, fatigue, constipation, anemia, vomiting, diarrhea, and skin lesions (rash, acne, pruritus, or petechiae) were non-specific and occurred in a few patients. One case each of Grade III neuritis and shock was reported and relieved after treatment (Table 5 5 ). None: no adverse effects 2 Study ID 2 Adverse effects of (number of cases) Chemo group Combination group DcLi2009L (Li et al., 2009 2009 ) None Fever, headache DcZhong2011L (Zhong et al., 2011 2011 ) Anemia (6), leucopenia (13), nausea (13), fever (3), rash, acne, pruritus (1), fatigue (8), febrile neutropenia (1) Anemia (4), leucopenia (10), nausea (9), fever (10), rash, acne, pruritus (9), fatigue (1), febrile neutropenia (0) DcYuan2011L (Yuan et al., 2011a 2011a ) Fever (2), chill (2) Fever (11), chill (8), shock (1) DcSheng2011L (Sheng et al., 2011 2011 ) Arrest of bone-marrow, gastrointestinal reactions Fever (1), arrest of bone-marrow, gastrointestinal reactions DcZhang2011C (Zhang et al., 2011 2011 ) DcYuan2011C (Yuan et al., 2011b 2011b ) None Fever (2) DcZhu2011C (Zhu et al., 2011 2011 ) None Fever (2) DcLi2012C (Li et al., 2012 2012 ) Arrest of bone-marrow, gastrointestinal reactions, peripheral neurotoxicity Fever (1), arrest of bone-marrow, gastrointestinal reactions, peripheral neurotoxicity DcRen2013B (Ren et al., 2013 2013 ) Vomiting (1), diarrhea (1), hepatic complications (2) Neuritis (1), vomiting (9), diarrhea (12), hepatic complications (4) DcYuan2013L (Yuan et al., 2013 2013 ) Anemia, skin petechiae, fatigue, oral pain, constipation, peripheral neuropathy Fever, anemia, skin petechiae, fatigue, oral pain, constipation, peripheral neuropathy DcNi2013B (Ni et al., 2013 2013 ) None Fever (3) DcGao2014G (Gao et al., 2014 2014 ) None Fever (9) Discussion 1 During the early stage of cancer, the immune system is capable of perceiving and eliminating cancer cells, but the efficacy is attenuated with the emergence of the rising number of strange antigens and immunosuppressed status because of the genetic abnormality in the development of cancer. The theory of immunosurveillance and immunoediting insists that cancer cells could escape from a balanced status controlled by the immune system and initiate growth (Dunn et al., 2004 2004 ). Existence of cancer could mislead myeloid cell differentiation towards immune-suppressor cells and suppress anti-tumor response (Gabrilovich et al., 2012 2012 ). As the lack of immune regulation has been accepted as one of hallmarks of cancer (Hanahan and Weinberg, 2011 2011 ), therapies that enhance anti-tumor immune response are valuable in cancer management. DCs were indispensable in presenting antigens, secreting cytokines, and inducing anti-tumor immune response in cancers. Anguille et al. ( 2014 2014 ) reviewed 38 clinical studies of DC-based immunotherapy in diverse cancers, and they showed that this immunotherapy had a survival benefit and the ability of eliciting an immune response even in advanced-stage patients. In vivo , CIK cells have shown an anti-tumor effect against several kinds of solid tumors in mice with SCID (Jiang et al., 2013 2013 ). A clinical trial of CIK therapy emerged in 1999, and the number has increased rapidly in the last fifteen years. A systematic review, which included eight trials comparing clinical outcome of CIK and non-CIK therapy, indicated a prolonged OS and DFS in patients with solid cancer (Ma et al., 2012 2012 ). Liu et al. ( 2013 2013 ) studied retinoblastoma cell lines cultured in vitro with tandem carboplatin-DC-CIK, which was preparatively pulsed with tumor antigens, providing evidence that carboplatin combined with DC-CIK cells therapy is superior to carboplatin alone in killing cancer cells. Treatment of carboplatin-DC-CIK was also found to increase cytotoxicity of DC-CIK treatment and sensitize cancer cells to DC-CIK cytotoxic response. Apoptosis was confirmed as a major mechanism underlying CIK cytotoxicity for the first time. According to a meta-analysis of 27 clinical studies on breast cancer, DC-CIK therapy prolonged 1-year survival, improved the quality-of-life, increased immunity function, and decreased cancer antigen (Wang et al., 2014b 2014b ). Most of current clinical studies focused on CIK or DC-CIK therapy were performed in China, of which phase I studies and retrospective studies were a major part. Singaporean researchers performed clinical trials on CIK cells, and reported a modest efficacy in hematological malignancy, which may be restricted by imperfect treatment protocol (Linn et al., 2012a 2012a ; 2012b 2012b ). Introna et al. ( 2007 2007 ; 2010 2010 ) from Italy conducted two phase I trials showing that the clinical use of CIK cells on leukemic patients after stem cell or cord blood cell transplantation is feasible and well-tolerated. Italian researchers Olioso et al. ( 2009 2009 ) tested the CIK therapy in six advanced lymphomas, five metastatic kidney carcinomas, and one hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The results showed that CIK cells could be easily applied clinically, representing a safe and efficient therapy to enhance immune function. The international registry on CIK cells (IRCC, http://www.cik-info.org http://www.cik-info.org ), established in 2010, is a global platform collecting and evaluating clinical trials about CIK cells, and helping researchers to build up a standard in CIK cell therapy. IRCC provides us with recommended analysis parameters and reporting standards, which will benefit patients on condition that there is more registration (Schmeel et al., 2014 2014 ). Meta-analysis is an optimal choice to analyze dozens of clinical studies. The main defects in existing meta-analysis about DC-CIK are that often non-RCTs are included and there is a non-unified regimen of groups. Our meta-analysis brings some new approaches to data reduction. (1) We analyzed current RCTs on DC-CIK therapy and provided an essential reference for evidence-based medicine. (2) Generally, our included studies displayed similar trends in some parameters, but our analysis quantified these trends to make it easier to draw definitive conclusions. (3) The analysis of different types of cancer makes it possible to determine which kind of patient should receive this therapy. In our study, DC-CIK therapy significantly prolonged OS (OR=0.31, P< 0.00001), 1-year DFS (OR=0.16, P= 0.01), and 3-year DFS (OR=0.32, P= 0.003), but the analysis of the 2-year DFS showed no difference (OR=0.49, P= 0.06), probably due to the lack of studies reporting DFS and the following reasons. Transfused CIK cells died out after the termination of treatment, and therefore it may barely prolong short-term survival. Wang et al. ( 2014b 2014b ) reported that DC-CIK therapy only prolongs 1-year OS. However, we found the influence of DC-CIK not only on short-term survival but also on long-term survival. The patients receiving DC-CIK therapy had significantly higher ORR (OR=0.54, P= 0.004) and DCR (OR=0.46, P= 0.001) than the patients who received chemotherapy only. Another meta-analysis of colon cancer showed significantly higher ORR but not DCR of DC-CIK chemotherapy compared with chemotherapy (Wang et al., 2014c 2014c ). Our analysis, covering relatively more studies and patients, may be more reliable. The levels of subtypes of T-lymphocyte in peripheral blood reflect the cellular immunity, which is critical in anti-tumor activity. Patients of various kinds of advanced cancer express less CD3 + and CD4 + T-lymphocytes and more CD8 + T-lymphocytes in peripheral blood than early stage patients or healthy people (Yu et al., 2014 2014 ). CD4 + T-lymphocytes are considered as helper T-lymphocytes in immune activity, while CD8 + T-lymphocytes induce immune suppression in cancers (McGray et al., 2014 2014 ). In our study, DC-CIK therapy up-regulated levels of CD3 + T-lymphocytes (OR=−11.65, P= 0.02), CD4 + T-lymphocytes (OR=−8.18, P< 0.0001), and ratio of CD4 + /CD8 + T-lymphocytes (OR=−0.40, P= 0.0006), indicating that DC-CIK cells enhance the immune activity. Efficacy assessments discussed above were performed among NSCLC, gastrointestinal cancer, and breast cancer. According to immunosurveillance theory, cancer originates from the inefficiency of the immune system or the impaired expression of tumor-associated antigens. It is common in different cancer types that cancer cells evade the recognition and elimination of the immune system (Schreiber et al., 2011 2011 ). Though strengthening the immune response, immunotherapy may exhibit different outcomes in different solid cancers due to their distinct characteristics (Conniot et al., 2014 2014 ). In our meta-analysis, the combination of chemotherapy and DC-CIK could significantly prolong 2-year OS and 3-year OS, as well as enhance immune activity in NSCLC patients and gastrointestinal cancer patients. For breast cancer, combination therapy showed better ORR and DCR, but the data of T-lymphocyte subtypes and OS were unreliable due to the limited studies (only one study). Relatively, combination therapy represented better applicability in gastrointestinal cancer (gastric cancer and colorectal cancer) than in NSCLC in terms of OS, but the improvements of cellular immunity in NSCLC were more evident than those in gastrointestinal cancer. Owing to the lack of RCTs and incomplete data of included studies, it was hard to draw a convincing conclusion when comparing efficacy between different types of cancer. Discrepancy of outcomes in different cancers may result from the tumor location, blood supply, or unexplained molecular mechanisms. Clinical researches combined with molecular biology studies would help us improve the design of immunotherapy and discover mechanisms underlying sensitivities to immunotherapy. At present, our meta-analysis indicated that immunotherapy significantly improve the OS and immune activity of NSCLC patients, OS of gastrointestinal cancer patients, and clinical response of breast cancer patients. The decision depends on the demand. Our results provide a reference for decision making in cancer treatment. Our study has several limitations. Included studies were all from China, leading to a regional limitation. Risk of reporting bias may imply insufficient reporting of primary outcome. Moreover, we mainly analyzed treatment efficacy in solid cancer, and more analysis is needed on different types of cancer. To define the appropriate application of combination therapy, standardized research protocols and exhaustive information of both hospitalization and follow-up are required. In conclusion, immunotherapy of DC-CIK cells improves chemotherapy on clinical response rates, survival of patients, and immune activity of patients with solid cancer, and induces no specific side effects, indicating that DC-CIK is a promising efficient therapeutic option against cancers. Further strict RCTs with no publishing bias should be designed to confirm the immunotherapeutic effects of DC-CIK cells. References S Anguille , EL Smits , E Lion , 等 . Clinical use of dendritic cells for cancer therapy . Lancet Oncol , 2014 . 15 ( 7 ): e257 - e267 . DOI: 10.1016/S1470-2045(13)70585-0 http://doi.org/10.1016/S1470-2045(13)70585-0 . Clinical use of dendritic cells for cancer therapy S Baek , SJ Lee , MJ Kim , 等 . Dendritic cell (DC) vaccine in mouse lung cancer minimal residual model; comparison of monocyte-derived DC vs. hematopoietic stem cell derived-DC . Immune Netw , 2012 . 12 ( 6 ): 269 - 276 . DOI: 10.4110/in.2012.12.6.269 http://doi.org/10.4110/in.2012.12.6.269 . Dendritic cell (DC) vaccine in mouse lung cancer minimal residual model; comparison of monocyte-derived DC vs. hematopoietic stem cell derived-DC J Conniot , JM Silva , JG Fernandes , 等 . Cancer immunotherapy: nanodelivery approaches for immune cell targeting and tracking . Front Chem , 2014 . 2 105 DOI: 10.3389/fchem.2014.00105 http://doi.org/10.3389/fchem.2014.00105 . Cancer immunotherapy: nanodelivery approaches for immune cell targeting and tracking GP Dunn , LJ Old , RD Schreiber . The immunobiology of cancer immunosurveillance and immunoediting . Immunity , 2004 . 21 ( 2 ): 137 - 148 . DOI: 10.1016/j.immuni.2004.07.017 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2004.07.017 . The immunobiology of cancer immunosurveillance and immunoediting DI Gabrilovich , S Ostrand-Rosenberg , V Bronte . Coordinated regulation of myeloid cells by tumours . Nat Rev Immunol , 2012 . 12 ( 4 ): 253 - 268 . DOI: 10.1038/nri3175 http://doi.org/10.1038/nri3175 . Coordinated regulation of myeloid cells by tumours D Gao , C Li , X Xie , 等 . Autologous tumor lysate-pulsed dendritic cell immunotherapy with cytokine-induced killer cells improves survival in gastric and colorectal cancer patients . PLoS ONE , 2014 . 9 ( 4 ): e93886 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0093886 http://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0093886 . Autologous tumor lysate-pulsed dendritic cell immunotherapy with cytokine-induced killer cells improves survival in gastric and colorectal cancer patients D Hanahan , RA Weinberg . Hallmarks of cancer: the next generation . Cell , 2011 . 144 ( 5 ): 646 - 674 . DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2011.02.013 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2011.02.013 . Hallmarks of cancer: the next generation MZ Hao , HL Lin , Q Chen , 等 . Efficacy of transcatheter arterial chemoembolization combined with cytokine-induced killer cell therapy on hepatocellular carcinoma: a comparative study . Chin J Cancer , 2010 . 29 ( 2 ): 172 - 177 . DOI: 10.5732/cjc.009.10410 http://doi.org/10.5732/cjc.009.10410 . Efficacy of transcatheter arterial chemoembolization combined with cytokine-induced killer cell therapy on hepatocellular carcinoma: a comparative study M Introna , G Borleri , E Conti , 等 . Repeated infusions of donor-derived cytokine-induced killer cells in patients relapsing after allogeneic stem cell transplantation: a phase I study . Haematologica , 2007 . 92 ( 7 ): 952 - 959 . DOI: 10.3324/haematol.11132 http://doi.org/10.3324/haematol.11132 . Repeated infusions of donor-derived cytokine-induced killer cells in patients relapsing after allogeneic stem cell transplantation: a phase I study M Introna , A Pievani , G Borleri , 等 . Feasibility and safety of adoptive immunotherapy with CIK cells after cord blood transplantation . Biol Blood Marrow Transplant , 2010 . 16 ( 11 ): 1603 - 1607 . DOI: 10.1016/j.bbmt.2010.05.015 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbmt.2010.05.015 . Feasibility and safety of adoptive immunotherapy with CIK cells after cord blood transplantation J Jiang , C Wu , B Lu . Cytokine-induced killer cells promote antitumor immunity . J Transl Med , 2013 . 11 ( 1 ): 83 DOI: 10.1186/1479-5876-11-83 http://doi.org/10.1186/1479-5876-11-83 . Cytokine-induced killer cells promote antitumor immunity H Li , C Wang , J Yu , 等 . Dendritic cell-activated cytokine-induced killer cells enhance the anti-tumor effect of chemotherapy on non-small cell lung cancer in patients after surgery . Cytotherapy , 2009 . 11 ( 8 ): 1076 - 1083 . DOI: 10.3109/14653240903121252 http://doi.org/10.3109/14653240903121252 . Dendritic cell-activated cytokine-induced killer cells enhance the anti-tumor effect of chemotherapy on non-small cell lung cancer in patients after surgery S Li , Y Li , J Liang , 等 . The study of clinical application of DC-CIK combined with chemotherapy on colon cancer . Chin J Immunol , 2012 . 9 835 - 839 . (in Chinese) . The study of clinical application of DC-CIK combined with chemotherapy on colon cancer YC Linn , LC Lau , KM Hui . Generation of cytokine-induced killer cells from leukaemic samples with in vitro cytotoxicity against autologous and allogeneic leukaemic blasts . Br J Haematol , 2002 . 116 ( 1 ): 78 - 86 . DOI: 10.1046/j.1365-2141.2002.03247.x http://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2141.2002.03247.x . Generation of cytokine-induced killer cells from leukaemic samples with in vitro cytotoxicity against autologous and allogeneic leukaemic blasts YC Linn , M Niam , S Chu , 等 . The anti-tumour activity of allogeneic cytokine-induced killer cells in patients who relapse after allogeneic transplant for haematological malignancies . Bone Marrow Transplant , 2012 . 47 ( 7 ): 957 - 966 . DOI: 10.1038/bmt.2011.202 http://doi.org/10.1038/bmt.2011.202 . The anti-tumour activity of allogeneic cytokine-induced killer cells in patients who relapse after allogeneic transplant for haematological malignancies YC Linn , HX Yong , M Niam , 等 . A phase I/II clinical trial of autologous cytokine-induced killer cells as adjuvant immunotherapy for acute and chronic myeloid leukemia in clinical remission . Cytotherapy , 2012 . 14 ( 7 ): 851 - 859 . DOI: 10.3109/14653249.2012.694419 http://doi.org/10.3109/14653249.2012.694419 . A phase I/II clinical trial of autologous cytokine-induced killer cells as adjuvant immunotherapy for acute and chronic myeloid leukemia in clinical remission L Liu , W Zhang , X Qi , 等 . Randomized study of autologous cytokine-induced killer cell immunotherapy in metastatic renal carcinoma . Clin Cancer Res , 2012 . 18 ( 6 ): 1751 - 1759 . DOI: 10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-11-2442 http://doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-11-2442 . Randomized study of autologous cytokine-induced killer cell immunotherapy in metastatic renal carcinoma P Liu , L Chen , X Huang . The antitumor effects of CIK cells combined with docetaxel against drug-resistant lung adenocarcinoma cell line SPC-A1/DTX in vitro and in vivo . Cancer Biother Radiopharm , 2009 . 24 ( 1 ): 91 - 98 . DOI: 10.1089/cbr.2008.0533 http://doi.org/10.1089/cbr.2008.0533 . The antitumor effects of CIK cells combined with docetaxel against drug-resistant lung adenocarcinoma cell line SPC-A1/DTX in vitro and in vivo Q Liu , Y Wang , H Wang , 等 . Tandem therapy for retinoblastoma: immunotherapy and chemotherapy enhance cytotoxicity on retinoblastoma by increasing apoptosis . J Cancer Res Clin Oncol , 2013 . 139 ( 8 ): 1357 - 1372 . DOI: 10.1007/s00432-013-1448-7 http://doi.org/10.1007/s00432-013-1448-7 . Tandem therapy for retinoblastoma: immunotherapy and chemotherapy enhance cytotoxicity on retinoblastoma by increasing apoptosis Y Ma , Z Zhang , L Tang , 等 . Cytokine-induced killer cells in the treatment of patients with solid carcinomas: a systematic review and pooled analysis . Cytotherapy , 2012 . 14 ( 4 ): 483 - 493 . DOI: 10.3109/14653249.2011.649185 http://doi.org/10.3109/14653249.2011.649185 . Cytokine-induced killer cells in the treatment of patients with solid carcinomas: a systematic review and pooled analysis AJ McGray , R Hallett , D Bernard , 等 . Immunotherapy-induced CD8 + T cells instigate immune suppression in the tumor . Mol Ther , 2014 . 22 ( 1 ): 206 - 218 . DOI: 10.1038/mt.2013.255 http://doi.org/10.1038/mt.2013.255 . Immunotherapy-induced CD8+ T cells instigate immune suppression in the tumor Z Ni , Q Fang , D Liu , 等 . Effect of DC-CIK combined with chemotherapy on immune function, progression-free survival and quality of life of patients with breast cancer . Matern Child Health Care China , 2013 . 28 ( 31 ): 5134 - 5137 . (in Chinese) . Effect of DC-CIK combined with chemotherapy on immune function, progression-free survival and quality of life of patients with breast cancer Q Niu , W Wang , Y Li , 等 . Cord blood-derived cytokine-induced killer cells biotherapy combined with second-line chemotherapy in the treatment of advanced solid malignancies . Int Immunopharmacol , 2011 . 11 ( 4 ): 449 - 456 . DOI: 10.1016/j.intimp.2010.12.014 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.intimp.2010.12.014 . Cord blood-derived cytokine-induced killer cells biotherapy combined with second-line chemotherapy in the treatment of advanced solid malignancies P Olioso , R Giancola , M di Riti , 等 . Immunotherapy with cytokine induced killer cells in solid and hematopoietic tumours: a pilot clinical trial . Hematol Oncol , 2009 . 27 ( 3 ): 130 - 139 . DOI: 10.1002/hon.886 http://doi.org/10.1002/hon.886 . Immunotherapy with cytokine induced killer cells in solid and hematopoietic tumours: a pilot clinical trial K Palucka , J Banchereau , I Mellman . Designing vaccines based on biology of human dendritic cell subsets . Immunity , 2010 . 33 ( 4 ): 464 - 478 . DOI: 10.1016/j.immuni.2010.10.007 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2010.10.007 . Designing vaccines based on biology of human dendritic cell subsets CC Pan , ZL Huang , W Li , 等 . Serum alpha-fetoprotein measurement in predicting clinical outcome related to autologous cytokine-induced killer cells in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma undergone minimally invasive therapy . Chin J Cancer , 2010 . 29 ( 6 ): 596 - 602 . DOI: 10.5732/cjc.009.10580 http://doi.org/10.5732/cjc.009.10580 . Serum alpha-fetoprotein measurement in predicting clinical outcome related to autologous cytokine-induced killer cells in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma undergone minimally invasive therapy J Ren , L Di , G Song , 等 . Selections of appropriate regimen of high-dose chemotherapy combined with adoptive cellular therapy with dendritic and cytokine-induced killer cells improved progression-free and overall survival in patients with metastatic breast cancer: reargument of such contentious therapeutic preferences . Clin Transl Oncol , 2013 . 15 ( 10 ): 780 - 788 . DOI: 10.1007/s12094-013-1001-9 http://doi.org/10.1007/s12094-013-1001-9 . Selections of appropriate regimen of high-dose chemotherapy combined with adoptive cellular therapy with dendritic and cytokine-induced killer cells improved progression-free and overall survival in patients with metastatic breast cancer: reargument of such contentious therapeutic preferences LC Schmeel , FC Schmeel , C Coch , 等 . Cytokine-induced killer (CIK) cells in cancer immunotherapy: report of the international registry on CIK cells (IRCC) . J Cancer Res Clin Oncol , 2014 . 141 ( 5 ): 839 - 849 . DOI: 10.1007/s00432-014-1864-3 http://doi.org/10.1007/s00432-014-1864-3 . Cytokine-induced killer (CIK) cells in cancer immunotherapy: report of the international registry on CIK cells (IRCC) IG Schmidt-Wolf , RS Negrin , HP Kiem , 等 . Use of a SCID mouse/human lymphoma model to evaluate cytokine-induced killer cells with potent antitumor cell activity . J Exp Med , 1991 . 174 ( 1 ): 139 - 149 . DOI: 10.1084/jem.174.1.139 http://doi.org/10.1084/jem.174.1.139 . Use of a SCID mouse/human lymphoma model to evaluate cytokine-induced killer cells with potent antitumor cell activity RD Schreiber , LJ Old , MJ Smyth . Cancer immunoediting: integrating immunity’s roles in cancer suppression and promotion . Science , 2011 . 331 ( 6024 ): 1565 - 1570 . DOI: 10.1126/science.1203486 http://doi.org/10.1126/science.1203486 . Cancer immunoediting: integrating immunity’s roles in cancer suppression and promotion C Sheng , F Bao , S Xu , 等 . Clinical research on chemotherapy combined with dendritic cell-cytokine induced killer cells for non-small cell lung cancer . J Pract Oncol , 2011 . 26 ( 5 ): 503 - 506 . (in Chinese) . Clinical research on chemotherapy combined with dendritic cell-cytokine induced killer cells for non-small cell lung cancer L Shi , Q Zhou , J Wu , 等 . Efficacy of adjuvant immunotherapy with cytokine-induced killer cells in patients with locally advanced gastric cancer . Cancer Immunol Immun , 2012 . 61 ( 12 ): 2251 - 2259 . DOI: 10.1007/s00262-012-1289-2 http://doi.org/10.1007/s00262-012-1289-2 . Efficacy of adjuvant immunotherapy with cytokine-induced killer cells in patients with locally advanced gastric cancer S Thanendrarajan , M Nowak , H Abken , 等 . Combining cytokine-induced killer cells with vaccination in cancer immunotherapy: more than one plus one? . Leuk Res , 2011 . 35 ( 9 ): 1136 - 1142 . DOI: 10.1016/j.leukres.2011.05.005 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.leukres.2011.05.005 . Combining cytokine-induced killer cells with vaccination in cancer immunotherapy: more than one plus one? D Wang , B Zhang , H Gao , 等 . Clinical research of genetically modified dendritic cells in combination with cytokine-induced killer cell treatment in advanced renal cancer . BMC Cancer , 2014 . 14 ( 1 ): 251 DOI: 10.1186/1471-2407-14-251 http://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2407-14-251 . Clinical research of genetically modified dendritic cells in combination with cytokine-induced killer cell treatment in advanced renal cancer ZX Wang , JX Cao , M Wang , 等 . Adoptive cellular immunotherapy for the treatment of patients with breast cancer: a meta-analysis . Cytotherapy , 2014 . 16 ( 7 ): 934 - 945 . DOI: 10.1016/j.jcyt.2014.02.011 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcyt.2014.02.011 . Adoptive cellular immunotherapy for the treatment of patients with breast cancer: a meta-analysis ZX Wang , JX Cao , ZP Liu , 等 . Combination of chemotherapy and immunotherapy for colon cancer in china: a meta-analysis . World J Gastroenterol , 2014 . 20 ( 4 ): 1095 - 1106 . DOI: 10.3748/wjg.v20.i4.1095 http://doi.org/10.3748/wjg.v20.i4.1095 . Combination of chemotherapy and immunotherapy for colon cancer in china: a meta-analysis D Yu , Y Han , Q Zhao , 等 . CD3 + CD4 + and CD3 + CD8 + lymphocyte subgroups and their surface receptors NKG2D and NKG2A in patients with non-small cell lung cancer . Asian Pac J Cancer Prev , 2014 . 15 ( 6 ): 2685 - 2688 . DOI: 10.7314/APJCP.2014.15.6.2685 http://doi.org/10.7314/APJCP.2014.15.6.2685 . CD3+ CD4+ and CD3+ CD8+ lymphocyte subgroups and their surface receptors NKG2D and NKG2A in patients with non-small cell lung cancer J Yuan , D Peng , J Li . Clinical effects of administering dendritic cells and cytokine induced killer cell combined with chemo therapy in the treatment of advanced non-small cell lung cancer . J Clin Orthop , 2011 . 16 ( 12 ): 1910 - 1911 . (in Chinese) . Clinical effects of administering dendritic cells and cytokine induced killer cell combined with chemo therapy in the treatment of advanced non-small cell lung cancer J Yuan , D Peng , J Li , 等 . Clinical research of dendritic cells combined with cytokine induced killer cells therapy for advanced colorectal cancer . Chin Gen Pract , 2011 . 12 4139 - 4141 . (in Chinese) . Clinical research of dendritic cells combined with cytokine induced killer cells therapy for advanced colorectal cancer Y Yuan , L Niu , F Mu , 等 . Therapeutic outcomes of combining cryotherapy, chemotherapy and DC-CIK immunotherapy in the treatment of metastatic non-small cell lung cancer . Cryobiology , 2013 . 67 ( 2 ): 235 - 240 . DOI: 10.1016/j.cryobiol.2013.08.001 http://doi.org/10.1016/j.cryobiol.2013.08.001 . Therapeutic outcomes of combining cryotherapy, chemotherapy and DC-CIK immunotherapy in the treatment of metastatic non-small cell lung cancer J Zhang , J Geng , Z Han , 等 . Clinical effects of treatment of dendritic cells combined with cytokine induced killer cells therapy in patients with advanced colon carcinoma . Acta Acad Med Xuzhou , 2011 . 31 ( 7 ): 457 - 459 . (in Chinese) . Clinical effects of treatment of dendritic cells combined with cytokine induced killer cells therapy in patients with advanced colon carcinoma R Zhong , J Teng , B Han , 等 . Dendritic cells combining with cytokine-induced killer cells synergize chemotherapy in patients with late-stage non-small cell lung cancer . Cancer Immunol Immun , 2011 . 60 ( 10 ): 1497 - 1502 . DOI: 10.1007/s00262-011-1060-0 http://doi.org/10.1007/s00262-011-1060-0 . Dendritic cells combining with cytokine-induced killer cells synergize chemotherapy in patients with late-stage non-small cell lung cancer R Zhong , B Han , H Zhong . A prospective study of the efficacy of a combination of autologous dendritic cells, cytokine-induced killer cells, and chemotherapy in advanced non-small cell lung cancer patients . Tumour Biol , 2014 . 35 ( 2 ): 987 - 994 . DOI: 10.1007/s13277-013-1132-1 http://doi.org/10.1007/s13277-013-1132-1 . A prospective study of the efficacy of a combination of autologous dendritic cells, cytokine-induced killer cells, and chemotherapy in advanced non-small cell lung cancer patients Y Zhu , J Liu , N Zhang , 等 . Clinical effects of treatment with comprehensive multiple autologous immune cells in patients with colorectal carcinoma . Acta Acad Med Xuzhou , 2011 . 9 631 - 636 . (in Chinese) . Clinical effects of treatment with comprehensive multiple autologous immune cells in patients with colorectal carcinoma Compliance with ethics guidelines Xiao-peng LAN, You-gen CHEN, Zheng WANG, Chuan-wei YUAN, Gang-gang WANG, Guo-liang LU, Shao-wei MAO, Xun-bo JIN, and Qing-hua XIA declare that they have no conflict of interest. This article does not contain any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of the authors. 10.1631/jzus.B1500003 Project supported by the Medical and Health Technology Development Project of Shandong Province, China (No. 2014WS0351) 2014-12-31 2015-08-10 2015-05-05 2022-01-05 Copyright © Zhejiang University and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2015 2015 Journal of Zhejiang University-SCIENCE B (Biomedicine and Biotechnology) 09 16